The blog of a Western fan, for other Western fans

A fine Western noir

Rawhide is a much underrated but
absolutely excellent Western.

Given that Tyrone Power had
been such a big star for Fox and was Jesse James in their big color picture of
the same name in 1939, it was perhaps surprising that they should have put him
in this apparently small, black & white B-Western in 1951. But it was a
high-quality picture in fact and Power was superb in it. He was not really a
Western hero. Oh, sure, every big studio star had to climb into the saddle occasionally
in those days, even if he were allergic to horses, and Power mounted up six times.

Power and Hayward: excellent combination
But apart
from Jesse James and Rawhide, two were Canadian Mountie
pictures, one was a Brigham Young biopic and in the other he was Zorro; they
hardly count as Westerns at all. Jesse James
notwithstanding, Rawhide was easily
the best he was in. In it he is gritty, tough and ready to fight with fist or
six-gun, a real Western lead. And he wears a great shirt.

The picture was directed – very
well directed too – by Henry Hathaway. He’d cut his Western teeth on a long
series of Zane Grey adaptations for Paramount in the 1930s, many with Randolph Scott,
and in 1940 did that Brigham Young film with Power. He later directed Gary Cooper in the first-class Garden of Evil
and John Wayne in several of his big hits, North to Alaska, The Sons of Katie Elder
and of course True Grit. So Hathaway
knew what he was doing in the West and he does a damn good job with Rawhide, which is pacey, gripping and
has excellent performances from the cast.

And the cast is top notch.
Apart from Power, aptly named, we have a tough, belligerent Susan Hayward,
magnificent in this. She first appears as an unmarried mother, quite shocking
for 1951 audiences. The scene where, holding the baby, she demands to be addressed
as Miss and not Mrs. Holt is very well handled. In fact it turns out the little
girl is her late sister’s child and she is going back East to take hthe infant back from the
placer camps in California to ‘civilization’. Full marks to Ms. Hayward for an
outstanding performance. She was another of the Garden of Evil alumni (where she also played a tough cookie) and
was also memorable in Canyon Passage,
The Lusty Men and The Revengers, all good Westerns and all
the better for having her in them.
She was terrific in Westerns
Then we have Edgar Buchanan as
the manager of the stage way-station, as grumpy and crusty as we would expect
from the excellent Edgar and one of his best roles. For the scene is set somewhere
in the Southwest, between Tucson, AZ and Huntsville, TX, so maybe southern
New Mexico, though it is not specified (in any case, beautiful scenery, very
well shot in Alabama Hills, Lone Pine locations by Milton R Krasner). Four bandits
have broken out of Huntsville and take over the staging post in order to rob
the stage of its bullion.

And the bandits are seriously
good. They are led by a gripping Hugh Marlowe as Zimmermann. Marlowe was better
known for his drama, crime and mystery thrillers but he was in seven Western
features (and some TV shows), including under Hathaway in Garden of Evil in ’54. Rawhide
was his first and what a pity he didn’t do more.
Marlowe: electrifying
His three henchmen are played
by Jack Elam, Dean Jagger and George Tobias, all terrific. It was one of Elam’s
earliest parts and one of his best – even possibly the very best. Right from
the get-go he appears as a manic, bloodthirsty villain, just out of two years
in the pen, and that squint-eyed, splay-toed, stooping figure is all that we
want Jack to be. The sheer evil glee with which he shoots at the baby girl (in
a scene that would never be allowed nowadays) is one of the most memorable
moments in Westerns. Jagger is the intellectually challenged Yancy, another
classy performance from this great actor, and Tobias is the loyal ox Gratz. It
really is one of the best gangs of western badmen ever assembled.
Elam: manic
And then other favorite Western
character actors make their appearance, such as Jeff Corey as the stage driver,
James Millican as the shotgun messenger and Kenneth Tobey as a Ward Bondish cavalry
lieutenant. You really couldn’t ask for a better cast.

Another excellent feature of
this movie is the music. It starts with a catchy, memorable tune worthy of a
big A-picture, dum-de-dum-de-dum, morphs into O Susanna as the stage bowls
along and gets terrifically dark when the sinister, threatening badmen are
holding the good folk hostage. It’s by Sol Kaplan and it’s one of my fave Western
scores. Kaplan only did B-Westerns but they included The Fiend Who Walked the West (because Fox re-used the score from The Day the Earth Stood Still). Good stuff.

The movie is written by Dudley
Nichols, so that explains the quality of the script. It was in fact Nichols’s
first Western since Stagecoach. The
following year he adapted the AB Guthrie Jr. novel for The Big Sky and in 1957 he did The Tin Star. That’s pedigree.
Wonderful locations, fine photography
There’s one bit that doesn’t
ring true, when bad Guy Marlowe tells Power that he is a green boy now but when
he grows it will be different. Marlowe was in fact only three years older than

I love the intro and what they
call an outro, as the voiceover (Gary Merrill) tells us about “the jackass mail”,
St Louis to San Francisco in 25 days and all for $200 American. In fact I love
the whole movie and do not really understand why it is so little thought of. It’s
a gripping Western noir that won few plaudits at the time – or since – and yet
is one of the best little Westerns the early 50s had to offer. It was
apparently a remake of Fox’s 1935 crime
melodrama Show Them No Mercy with
Rochelle Hudson and Cesar Romero, which I haven’t seen. I doubt it could be as
good as this. It’s not often I award four revolvers out of five but this movie deserves it.


7 Responses

  1. I love this movie, too. It's very tight and the sense of menace is palpable. And you are 100% right about Marlowe. He's terrific in this picture; he was largely wasted in minor pictures or weak characters, but he is riveting here. I wish he had made more pictures like it.

  2. Yup. Funny, though, that you and I are the only people on the planet who know how good this Western is.

    1. one more vote for the awesomeness of this movie – Hathaway's a terrific director and this is one of his finest films.

    2. # Me too! Rawhide is a great film. Elam is a genuinely terrifying psycho. I like the way the corny opening music gives way to western noir.

  3. Here goes, Jeff. I've watched as many westerns as you have. I'm a pathological western addict, hopelessly hooked by everything to do with the genre. I've met and interviewed Rod Steiger, Robert Altman, Charles Bronson, JD Cannon, Vincent Gardenia, Anthony Franciosa and a couple of others I'd rather not mention. I didn't exactly interview Bronson. Not many people did. Generally speaking, he didn't give interviews. The only one I recall was on the release of Breakheart Pass, and Jill Ireland answered some of the questions for him.

    All this is to show my credentials before I make a controversial statement. I say Hathaway's From Hell to Texas is a superb movie, possibly a GREAT one. So Don Murray was and still is largely unknown. Does that matter? The hell it does. It's actually refreshing to watch a lesser known player take the lead in a relatively prestigious studio oater – and succeed wonderfully.

    A fine cast backs him up magnificently, especially Chill Wills, Diane Varsi and Dennis Hopper, legendary these days but unknown in the late '50s. Then there's the magnificent RG Armstrong, such a powerful actor he could be terrifying in the right part – see his turn as the jailer in Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid. For me, the movie comes above The Searchers. It uses the landscape as well as Ford, and has none of the comedy crap that rings false, like the squirm-inducing interludes with Ken Curtis. It gets on with the story and sticks with it without a trace of sentimentality. I'll be gunned down at dawn for saying this, but fair's fair. Hathaway and his team deserve the highest praise for their achievement. This films is shockingly little-known and I'll yell in support of it until I go to Boot Hill.

    1. Hi Bill
      I admire your enthusiasm and it's nice to have a perhaps underrated Western that one really likes. Rawhide and From Hell to Texas are similar in this.
      Personally, I would put From Hell to Texas in the very good rather than the great category, but that's just an opinion. I was quite complimentary about it, I recall, in my Dec 2010 review,
      Thanks for your comment. Nice to hear from a fellow obsessive!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.