No one would pretend that these pictures were major A-Westerns, and they were done with minimal budgets and slightly less famous casts. But they weren’t bad. Selander saw to that. A low-budget Western artist he may have been but he certainly got pace into his pictures.
Like Quincannon, The Broken Star does rather suffer from its top star. This time it’s Howard Duff. Duff did in fact lead or co-star in a few Westerns but he wasn’t my cup of tea. He had been Sam Spade on the radio and when he moved to TV and features he was never really in any danger of winning an Oscar. He was tepid at best opposite Ann Blyth in Red Canyon, with Yvonne de Carlo in Calamity Jane and Sam Bass and paired with Mona Freeman in The Lady from Texas. Blyth and De Carlo got top billing, above Duff. The Broken Star was, though, quite unusual in that the top-billed star played an out-and-out bad guy. It did happen (see, for example, The Black Dakotas) but it was rare.
But the film does have some quality. It was written by John C Higgins, who had produced the screenplays for quite a few of those gritty Anthony Mann noirs in the 1940s, and indeed, The Broken Star was a Western version of Higgins’s Shield for Murder, a picture directed by Howard Koch. In the hands of an Anthony Mann, with someone like Robert Mitchum in the lead and with cinematography by, say, James Wong Howe, The Broken Star could have been a fine picture, to rank with the likes of Blood on the Moon or Pursued. As it was, with Howard Duff and in the hands of Lesley Selander, low-budget movie helmsman nonpareil, it just became another B-Western.
Duff is crooked deputy Frank Smeed in Arizona, who in the first reel cold-bloodedly murders a certain Alvorado (Felipe Turich, uncredited) and steals the $8000 in gold pieces that Alvorado was keeping for rich landowner Thornton Wills, a faux-charmant Sydney Greenstreet-type figure (portly Henry Calvin, Sergeant Garcia in Disney’s Zorro). Wills doesn’t care for this at all and there’s quite a good scene where he alternately threatens Smeed coldly and cheerfully calls the line dance at his barbecue.
Unfortunately for Deputy Smeed, his crime was witnessed by an Apache ranch hand, Natchez (Joe Dominguez), and this will be his undoing. Natchez was a name for Cochise’s son Naiche but I don’t think it’s him.
There are some nice southern Arizona locations shot by cinematographer William Margulies, who also did Quincannon, Frontier Scout for Bel-Air the same year (in color, in Utah) and had also shot Fort Yuma and Revolt at Fort Laramie, both visually good Westerns.
The ruthless rancher Wills has two gunmen in his pay, obviously (you couldn’t be a ruthless rancher without henchmen, it wasn’t allowed). They are Messendyke and Van Horn (Joel Ashley and John Pickard) but Messrs. Messendyke and Van Horn are not the sharpest knives in the drawer. In fact they are as dumb as they are brutal.
There’s a glam señorita, Conchita (Almeria-born Lita Baron, talent-spotted by her future husband Rory Calhoun, and a gunslingerette in the Don ‘Red’ Barry Z-Western Jesse James’ Women), who sings a rather peppy song in the cantina, I Hate You, and wields a whip the while. She’s Alvorado’s cousin so has a vested interest in bringing the murderer to book. This Conchita is the amour of the other deputy, the good one, Bill Gentry (Bill Williams), and vice-versa, let it be said; they are like two turtle doves. Bill is conflicted because he believes his friend Smeed, who once saved his life, yet also believes Conchita, who discovers what a bad egg Smeed is.
Luckily there’s also a sheriff (good old Addison Richards) with professional integrity who is more than a little skeptical of Smeed’s concocted story of self-defense. And Smeed feels himself obliged to murder his way out of the jam he is in, slaying the Apache witness to his first killing.
I must say, though, that the sheriff and good deputy are incredibly dumb because before Smeed gets him, Natchez writes a brief note affirming Smeed’s guilt yet the lawmen are entirely unable to understand a word of it because it is in Spanish. Doh.
There’s a fair bit of action, a fistfight in the saloon, a sheriff’s posse, gunpowder in a mine and so forth, all in good Lesley Selander style.
Once rumbled, Smeed persuades crooked Indian agent Carleton (our old pal Douglas Fowley) to help him get across the border into Mexico, which Carleton agrees to do for half the loot, but each double-crosses the other and it all ends in tears.
Well, well, it’s a perfectly acceptable mid-50s Western as long as you are not too demanding. As I said, though, you just get the feeling that it could have been superb given the right personnel and budget.
A pleasure to read your excellent take on this one Jeff.
I too thought the square dance scene was a hoot-played to perfection
I also,liked Lita's whip weilding song-while the terrified looking
male patrons watch in stoned silence.
For me the film is part Western, part thriller, part parody and most
of it works pretty well.
What's next on the Bel Air roster I ask-THE OUTLAW'S SON perhaps.
Dane Clark,never a natural for Westerns,works flat out to save
the film,but a decidely second string cast (especially in minor
roles) more or less sink the project.
The film proves what an asset the likes of John Dehner,Leo Gordon
and Lee Van Cleef were. With those three on board THE OUTLAW'S SON
would have been a far,far better film.
The early Bel Air Selanders were the best especially WAR PAINT,
THE YELLOW TOMAHAWK and FORT YUMA.
Sadly THE YELLOW TOMAHAWK is no longer available in color but I
understand that a master neg does exist.Furthermore these
Selander cavalry films had far superior casts to the films that
I hadn't quite picked up on the parody angle but maybe you have a point.
I must seek out The Outlaw's Son; I don't remember it at all. War Paint, Yellow T and Ft Yuma yes, and I've already reviewed those. Fort Yuma is my favorite.
I'm very much enjoying these excellent reviews of lesser but still fairly entertaining westerns, Jeff. John clearly is too and I suspect Walter feels much the same.
"BROKEN STAR" is the only one of the last 3 reviewed that I have actually seen. Really quite enjoyed it but then you can add my name to the roster of Selanderites. One of my heroes.
Glad you enjoy them!
Jerry, yes I have been enjoying Jeff's reviews. I think these movies deserve their moment in the sun.