The blog of a Western fan, for other Western fans

City Slickers (Columbia, 1991)

with Cows



After some 1960s-ish cartoon titles
and a (rather overdone) comedy version of the bull-running in Pamplona (an event
in which I always cheer for the bulls which catch the stupid men) we are presented
with an urban comedy in which New Yorkers say witty things. Have we strayed
into a Woody Allen picture?

is only a Western by a great stretch of
the meaning of the word. Yet it does have Western themes and we’ll give it a

Three guys (Billy Crystal, Daniel Stern,
Bruno Kirby) have a midlife crisis and decide to take a two-week vacation
driving cattle from New Mexico to Colorado. So we have the age-old plot of the
Easterner tenderfoot out West, which has been going ever since silent movies
began. The midlife crisis is, I must say, brilliantly defined by the movie’s
producer and star, Mr. Crystal, in a scene in which he tells schoolchildren
(who appear to have Mrs. Thatcher as their class teacher) how their lives will
pan out. It is bleak and funny in equal measure.
The city-slicker trio arrives
As the trio arrive out West, the
color gets brighter and we see lovely New Mexico locations shot by Dean Semler (Dances with Wolves, Lonesome Dove,
Appaloosa, Young Guns
) and the music surges into stirring, sub-Bernstein Magnificent Seven-style orchestral richness
(it’s actually by Marc Shaiman and Thomas Richard Sharp). And after a build-up,
there, in an entrance to die for, is Jack Palance as the trail boss Curly,
feared by all (“Did you see how leathery he was? He was like a saddle bag with
eyes.”) Palance strikes a match by scraping it down his cheek. Phew, we think,
it’s a Western after all.
Palance allowed to overact but gets away with it
Crystal, his writers Lowell Ganz and
Babaloo Mandel and/or the director Ron Underwood (no Western form) had clearly
seen and were probably admirers of Red River. There are various references, one even explicit (“the Yahoo moment”).
Of course, they have about ten cows so this picture doesn’t have quite the epic
sweep of Howard Hawks’s, even if Palance does go for a Wayne-Dunson vibe. There’s
also a Deliverance parody aspect.

There is (there had to be) a stampede,
or, as one of the city slickers shouts, “The cows are going away!” It is
set off by Crystal using his battery-operated grinder on his tropical roast
coffee beans. Unfortunately catching the runaways is hard because Crystal has
what he calls a roping disability – despite much practice he has never mastered
the lariat. But gradually, as we guessed might happen, the Easterner learns,
and after delivering a calf he earns the highest possible accolade: Curly says,
“Good job, cowboy.”
“The cows are going away!”
There has to be a river crossing too,
naturally, and Crystal finally and heroically manages his rope. Left without a
boss (for such a dominant part, Palance’s appearance is very short lived) the
greenhorns man up, rather like the boys left without John Wayne in The Cowboys, and bring the herd in, as
Curly would have wanted. In a symbolic moment Crystal abandons his baseball cap
for a Stetson.

There are some very funny lines and the
whole show is certainly entertaining. It works. You get the impression that city slickers
the cast and crew may have been but they evidently loved the Western, as,
indeed, who among us does not? For did we not, we would be cast into outer
darkness. And wouldn’t be reading this blog.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.