Jeff Arnold’s West

The blog of a Western fan, for other Western fans

The Ballad of Lefty Brown (A24, 2017)


The sidekick leads


The Ballad of Lefty Brown was released at the South by Southwest Film Festival in March last year. It had an estimated budget of $8 million. By the end of the year it had, according to IMDb, grossed $5,559. Oh dear. Because it’s actually rather good.


For one thing, it’s visually fine, with lovely photography by David McFarland of quite stunning Montana locations. The ghost town of Bannack was used for a lot of it, and very atmospheric it is too. Bannack is famous as the place where Sheriff Plummer and two of his deputies were hanged, without trial, in 1864, and that is appropriate given the subject matter of this picture.



DP McFarland


For another thing, Bill Pullman is superb as the titular Lefty. Mr Pullman has not specialized in our noble genre but he was Ed Masterson in Kevin Costner’s Wyatt Earp, and, more importantly, he directed and starred in the second-best of the many screen versions of The Virginian, in 2000. He gives us a splendid performance as limping, aging Lefty, a bit of a shambling ne’er-do-well on the whole but with, it becomes evident, the heart of a lion. Interviewed, Pullman said, “It was more the perception of characters around him, that he was a fool.” Pullman plays Lefty close to the edge of comedy but remains on the grimly serious side of it. Back in the day it might have been tempting to go for the Walter Brennan or even Gabby Hayes ‘cranky old-timer’ approach but this Lefty is much less comic than those. Lefty Brown was, according to the IMDb trivia page, based on the gunslinger Lefty BJ Wheeler, but I don’t know who that is and can’t find anything about him. Can you tell us more, dear reader?



Pullman is a right-handed Lefty


Peter Fonda’s in it too, as rancher Edward Johnson, but Mr Fonda seems to make it his business these days to appear in Westerns briefly, maybe so they can put his name on the DVD box, and then get written out in the first reel. Cameos, they used to call them. He plays what we think will be the leading figure in the story, Johnson, an ex-lawman who has a rough way with malefactors (in the opening scenes he hangs a man without trial who shot another over a $2 poker game) but he has become Senator Johnson now and is off to DC. Just before leaving, though, he departs with Lefty after some rustlers of his horses and is (spoiler alert – stop reading here) surprisingly shot in the head, with unsurprisingly fatal results, by said rustlers, and lies dead on the prairie.



Fonda appears, briefly


The senator’s widow blames Lefty, though unfairly: the shot came out of the blue from a Sharps at long range. Mrs Johnson is played by Kathy Baker (whom I think of as Joanne in The Ranch) and she is a tough lady. She casually kills a rattler with her parasol on the ranch and she often sets her jaw in a way that resembles granite.


Kathy Baker is the senator’s widow


But the senator didn’t leave a will and the law says that the ranch must now go to his nearest male relative. The widow is miffed. Enter (fictional) Governor Jimmy Bierce to help by forging a will, the great friend of the family, played by Jim Caviezel, one of those actors who believes fashionably that if you deliver your lines in a loud whisper it will be more meaningful and earnest, whereas in fact it’s just silly and annoying.



Governor Caviezel


The governor is accompanied by another bosom pal, famous US Marshal Tom Harrah, the subject of sensational dime novels, played by Glaswegian Tommy Flanagan, who is, for me, Chibs Telford in Sons of Anarchy. He’s rather good as the ex-alcoholic (he is of course not the first lawman who took to the bottle in a Western) who has cleaned up but will backslide under the strain of the forthcoming events. These people, the senator, the governor, the marshal, the senator’s wife and his partner Lefty, were intimate friends and have come up together in the world. Nothing can separate them. Or can it?



Marshal Tom


Just before dying, the senator had given Lefty his rather fine rifle but Lefty doesn’t feel worthy of it and inters it. In doing so, he makes a vow, saying, “I’m gonna get that sonofabitch [the man who shot the senator] or die tryin’. My word ain’t worth much but on this it is.” So it becomes a pursuit/revenge drama – and rather a good one.


On his hunt, Lefty comes across a boy, Jeremiah (Diego Josef) and this lad, who reminds me a little of the Schofield Kid in Unforgiven, is sort of adopted by Lefty and joins in the chase. The youngster has a fancy two-gun rig and is mockingly called Wild Bill by Lefty.



Lefty gets an apprentice


Now Marshal Tom arrives, the kid’s great hero from those novels. The governor has sent him to get Lefty back: the Army will find the killers. But Lefty will have none of it. He made a vow. And he persuades Tom to join them, so now they are a posse.


Well, thanks to Lefty they do finally come up on the base assassin, one Frank Baines (Joe Anderson) and his loathsome gang. Lefty will come into their cabin from the back, Tom from the front, while the boy is ordered to wait, holding the horses. Naturally, he won’t.


Just then a fellow in a suit appears, Mr Crobley (Adam O’Byrne) and it seems he is the governor’s man, and he has money for the villains. Was it blood money? Had the governor paid the outlaws to kill the senator? Ah, there’s the rub.


Anyway, there’s a shoot-out, the boy Jeremiah is shot, the marshal slides back into the bottle and leaves, and Lefty is left in the soup.



Joe Anderson as very villainous killer Frank Baines, photo by Ezra Olsen


How it pans out, whether the governor was a false friend, if the boy survives, all of this I shall not tell you, dear reader. Wouldn’t want to spoil your fun. I can reveal, however, that there’s a good last-reel showdown in Bannack (the Meade Hotel features strongly) and there are deaths.


The film was, dare I say it, a tad long and could probably have done with sharper editing. But the actors were all good, the plot solid, and there were enough references to older Westerns to keep us entertained.


I think the amount the movie grossed must be a mistake. Anyway, they’ll recoup more with DVD sales and TV rights. I bought a DVD, so that’s another $9.99 to the good.



More than watchable, I’d say.


9 Responses

  1. Jeff, I knew that you would like this Western. I bought it at Wal-Mart earlier this year and I recommend it for viewing, because unlike most recent Westerns this is a rather good one. THE BALLAD OF LEFTY BROWN was a pleasant surprise for me, because I knew nothing about it. I'm not going to reveal anything more, because fellow viewers enjoy.

    The movie toured the festival circuit during 2017 and was popular with most audiences. It received a week of viewing in 2 movie theaters and brought in $7,856. I think the owners of this movie knew that the audience for it would be DVD and TV viewers. The movie was also sold to DirectTV for viewing.

    I have never read or heard of a left-handed gunfighter named BJ Wheeler. There was Ben Wheeler, a Texas lawman turned outlaw, who was lynched after attempting to rob a bank in Medicine Lodge, Kansas in 1884.

  2. Jeff, I'd like to know who throws those trivia items into IMDb without naming a source. I know there are local gunslingers, who never made national headlines in the NATIONAL POLICE GAZETTE. BJ Wheeler might have been one of the unheralded local gunslingers. My Grand Uncle Bob P______ was a local gunslinger. He spent time in a state prison farm for attempted murder. He did make local headlines for the shooting and while he was "on the lam." He was hiding out from a posse in some rough terrain called "Devil's Cellar." Uncle Bob finally gave himself up, because Winter wasn't the best time to be out in that neck of the woods.

  3. Jeff, I don't know if you would want to claim kin to Uncle Bob P_____ or not. He was just plain mean and he liked for everyone to know it. His weapon of choice was a single barrel shotgun. He carried it with him at all times. When I watch the movie WILL PENNY(1967) and see Preacher Quint(Donald Pleasence) with his single barrel shotgun, I think of Uncle Bob. Not that Uncle Bob was a religious fanatic, because he wasn't and religion had nothing to do with his being mean.

  4. Joe Anderson looks like John Dehner on your picture, quite a filiation ! Bannack is one of the loveliest and most atmospheric ghost towns of the whole West (Montana being one of its loveliest state). Beside of the Plummer/Vigilantes fascinating and until today controversial story, the former state capital is also famous because of the panic created by the Nez Perce flight of 1877. After the battle of Big Hole, the Indians were heading straight for Bannack. People from around the area gathered in Bannack to seek protection, building lookouts for early warning. Expecting a siege, the local water supply was barricaded, women and children were gathered in the rare brick buildings and the still existing courthouse. Although the Indians killed a few settlers, they never came close to Bannack. We are still expecting a good western inspired by this legendary epic adventure of the Nez Perce flight. JM

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *