Jeff Arnold’s West

The blog of a Western fan, for other Western fans

Vengeance Valley


Next time you point a gun at me, shoot


We are in the throes of looking at Western novels and the movies made from them, and today another pair, this time both good: Vengeance Valley, the novel by Luke Short, 1949, and the MGM movie of the same name, 1951.


Frederick D Glidden (1908 – 1975) was a fine writer of Western stories and one of my favorite authors. More about him tomorrow. His books are tightly-plotted, full of authentic detail and have strong, memorable characters. He wrote under the nom de plume Luke Short, a moniker he presumably borrowed from the dandy and gambler-gunfighter of that name (1854 – 1893) – another interesting character, but that’ll be for another day.



But the writer Short is definitely worth reading. He wrote dozens of novels, from The Feud at Single Shot (1935) to Trouble Country (1976, published posthumously).


A remarkable number were turned into films. This is because the books were shortish and lent themselves to cinematic treatment, especially because, as I have said above, their plots and characters were so strong, they were full of action and they reeked of authenticity. In fact when I read them (or re-read them!) I even find myself ‘casting’ the ones that weren’t movies, imagining this or that actor in the roles. Randolph Scott, often.


But the 1949 novel Vengeance Valley is a good example of one that was filmed.


The 1951 Western movie that MGM made of it has an almost documentary feel to it at times as we get a cattle-drive with voiceover commentary by one of the drovers (Carleton Carpenter, very well played). The cowboy scenes are true-to-life and there is skillful cutting out of steers to admire. There are impressive numbers of cattle – no ultra-low buget cowboy movie this.



But it’s also a family drama. Noirish Westerns which told of bitter family conflict had been all the rage in the late 40s, and this one was somewhat in that tradition, with its semi-Cain and Abel aspect. It was the tale of how the misdeeds of a wastrel, ne’er-do-well son, Lee Strobie (Robert Walker), are foiled by the sturdy, decent adopted son and foreman, Owen Daybright (Burt Lancaster). You can tell Lee is a bad one when he says to his wife, after beating a horse, “A good whipping never hurt any filly” (a line not in the book).


Bad guy and good guy


Walker was a tragic character, who was twice divorced by the age of thirty and suffered from alcoholism and mental illness. He died in August 1951, aged 32, of what is described as “adverse reaction to prescription drugs”, only six months after the première in Cañon City of Vengeance Valley, the movie. He’s probably best remembered for his role in Hitchcock’s Strangers on a Train, released after his death. Westernwise, he only did Vengeance Valley and the turgid and dull The Sea of Grass (1947): he was a wastrel son in both.


Tragic life


As for Burt, he would of course become one of the leading Western actors, well remembered for the likes of Vera Cruz and Apache, both helmed by Robert Aldrich in 1954, his steely Wyatt Earp in the John Sturges-directed Gunfight at the OK Corral (1957) and his superb performance in John Huston’s The Unforgiven (1960). I am also especially fond of two of his later oaters, Valdez is Coming (1971) and Ulzana’s Raid (1972). He led in fifteen altogether. But Vengeance Valley was his very first – and an excellent start.


His first Western


The old rancher, Arch Strobie (Ray Collins) pretends otherwise but knows, deep down, that his son is no good. The film makers have put Arch on crutches, like Edward G Robinson in The Violent Men, which he wasn’t in the book; it isn’t quite clear why – perhaps to make him more vulnerable, or to justify his lack of control over the ranch.It’s quite a daring theme for 1949/1951. A town girl (Sally Forrest) has an illegitimate baby and will not reveal the identity of the father. It is clear to us from the first chapter (and first reel) that it’s Lee. Lily’s brothers, the Faskens, arrive, played in the movie by John Ireland and Hugh O’Brian, both very good (and the latter very unEarpish). They will have the name of the father and force a marriage or there will be hell to pay. Because Owen generously gave the girl some money, they are convinced he’s the dad.


You can spot in minor parts (but don’t blink or you’ll miss them) stocky Ted de Corsia, good old Will Wright, the Old Ranger Stanley Andrews, Glenn Strange the Great and soon-to-be regular heavy Robert J Wilke.


The usual cheesy studio still


There’s good Colorado scenery (round Cañon City, where many of the early silent Westerns were filmed) photographed by George J Folsey.


The music is low-key, not intrusive, but subtly good. It was by Rudolph Kopp, who the same year wrote for the fine Westward the Women.The Short story (as it were) is adapted for the screen by Irving Ravetch, later writer of Hud and The Cowboys. He did a good job. Several important changes are made apart from the detail of the crutches. Chiefly, the characters of Jen, a neighboring rancher, and Edith, Lee’s wife, have been combined. Owen loves rancher Jen in the book and rather despises the gold-digger and unWestern Edith, but in the movie, he and the Jen/Edith figure (Joanne Dru, Mrs Ireland, in fact, of Red River and She Wore a Yellow Ribbon fame) are in love. While changes of this kind are often worse than the original book, in this case it adds well to the rivalry between Lee and Owen and is probably better.Another change is made in the ending but I will not discuss that here to avoid spoiling it for you if you have not read the book and/or seen the movie. Perish the thought.


Burt stands for no nonsense when one of the Fasken boys points a gun at him. He says, “You’ve scared me twice tonight. Next time you point a gun at me, shoot.” The bad man later takes him at his word but should have known better.Richard Thorpe directed tidily. He had been making two-reelers and low-budget Westerns, especially with Jay Wilsey and Buddy Roosevelt, since the early 1920s. His first talkie oater was The Utah Kid in 1930 with Rex Lease. He went on to do Jailhouse Rock.


Old hand at Westerns


Vengeance Valley is no epic with sweeping, nation-building themes. Short’s books weren’t like that; he was more interested in the intense interplay of a small number of characters, rather in the way those late 50s Budd Boetticher/Randolph Scott Westerns were. But it is a good story and Lancaster does an excellent job.


Bosley Crowther in The New York Times liked it, calling it “creditable entertainment”. He said, “The setting is the range country of the Rockies and the action includes scenes of noisy, lowing cattle, hard-riding cowpokes, rustling and a couple of lusty fights, with and without sixguns. Vengeance Valley has a considerable amount of excitement, and there is an almost documentary quality about the long sequences which provide a graphic picture of what it is like to be out on the range at round-up time. Richard Thorpe has directed these scenes expertly.” But the critic was uncertain that the film was entirely suitable for younger audiences. “It is, however, a Western which might give the kiddies some unnecessary ideas about life in the open spaces”


According to MGM records, the picture made a good profit of $841,000. For some reason the studio never renewed the copyright; this means that it’s in the public domain. The downside of that is that copies around are often very poor quality, so beware. But if you can find a good print, it’s worth it.


Luke Short

3 Responses

  1. Thanks for reminding me about this one Jeff. It turns out that it was in my collection in the middle of a 50 dvd pack titled “Western Classics” (in this case a term loosely used), most of which aren’t very good although it does also contain “Angel and the Badman,” Scott’s “Abilene Town,” “McLintock!” and “The Grand Duel” (sorry that one’s a “spag”). Anyway I forgot how good Vengeance is. A tight little oater with a great cast and Lancaster is always worth the price of admission.

    1. Agreed, and any Luke Short story is going to be good too.
      I also have some boxed sets of ‘classic’ Westerns which aren’t but such collections can be a cheap way to get movies you can’t find elsewhere.

  2. Funny to learn that the première was given far from the Hollywood lights in Cañon City. Mostly famous for its prisons and penitentiary, it is justifying its nicknames, the City of prisons or even better the Alcatraz of the Rockies…
    Do not miss the Museum of Colorado Prisons if you are the area… it shares his walls with the Colorado Territorial Correctional Facility (!) itself nicknamed “Old Max”. It was built in 1868 before Colorado was even a state, making it the state’s oldest prison.
    In 1948, the city gave its name to a Noir film about a prison break starring a very western cast with Scott Brady, Jeff Corey, DeForest Kelly and Whit Bissell. The warden was playing his own role… Not far, to get a breath of air, you can also admire the Royal Gorge Bridge standing high over the Arkansas river rapids. Several westerns had been shot in the area, among them Saddle the Wind, Hathaway’s True Grit, The Cow-boys, The White Buffalo etc. The local tourism office is touting that even Stagecoach was shot there but I do not see which moments…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Comments