Jeff Arnold’s West

The blog of a Western fan, for other Western fans

Gunsight Ridge (UA, 1957)


Joel is a Wells, Fargo man (again)


Gunsight Ridge is a minor Western noir. I don’t know if it was shown as a second feature but it certainly has the air of one. It’s still good, though.


It’s got Joel McCrea in it, for one thing. He was never less than excellent in oaters. Here he is an enigmatic Westerner, ready to switch on the Irish charm when the colleens are around, but tough as all get-out underneath. An ideal part for Joel. It was his 26th big-screen Western (depending on your definition) and one of four he did in ’57 (the others being The Oklahoman, Trooper Hook and The Tall Stranger), so he was certainly a fan of the genre.



Joel does his thing


It was directed by Francis D Lyon (1905 – 96), not the greatest of artists really. He was a former editor (he had worked on parts of Red River) who helmed fairly routine pictures from the mid-50s on.  He did mostly TV work but he did direct two McCrea oaters, this one and The Oklahoman, as well as Escort West with Victor Mature.



Director Lyon


The producer of Gunsight Ridge was Robert Bassler, another former editor who went on to produce some big pictures for Fox (including the fun A Ticket to Tomahawk and the Dale Robertson oater The Silver Whip) but who flopped on the dire Gentlemen Marry Brunettes and was relegated to TV.



Producer Bassler


It was shot in a nice black & white (and the modern print is good) with locations in and around Old Tucson (like Trooper Hook) by Ernest Laszlo, no less, so is quite classy from the visual point of view.



Cinematographer Laszlo


There’s some nice dialogue, by Talbot and Elizabeth Jennings. This was Elizabeth’s only contribution to the fifth art but Talbot, who was twice nominated for an Oscar (though not, sadly, for a Western), did the screenplay of a few oaters, and one of his stories became The Sons of Katie Elder. I liked this exchange:

 – Stage passenger: Seems like I ought to place you, but I can’t.
 – Mike Ryan (McCrea): Can I be of any help?
 – Where you from?
 – Well, almost any place you can get and some you can’t.
 – In what capacity?
 – Well, that depends on where I go.
 – No doubt you’ve got something quite special off in Bancroft.
 – That depends on Bancroft.

 – I can ask more questions and find out less from you then any man I ever knew.

– Kind of a natural gift.


And this one, between four ne’er-do-well cowpokes:

 – Where are we gonna get some grub at?
 – We’ll pick up supplies in Clarksville.
 – Where’s that?
 – Right where they built it. Where did you think it would be?



Talbot Jennings, writer


The bad guy is second-billed Mark Stevens. I’m not the greatest Stevens fan, though I think he was very good as Jack Slade. He was the former nightclub singer and stage actor Richard Stevens who got a contract with Fox. Darryl Zanuck changed his name, darkened his red hair and had the freckles covered up, and he specialized in noirs, often in supporting roles. He was sometimes branded a lesser John Payne. As John Payne was regarded as a lesser Alan Ladd, that wasn’t too much of a compliment. Westernwise, he was third billed in Roaring Guns in 1944, led in Sand in ’49 and then came his best-ever role in Allied Artists’ Jack Slade, with Dorothy Malone, in ’53. After that it was mostly TV work but he came back to the big screen, leading in Gunsmoke in Tucson and Gun Fever (both 1958). He ended his Western career with a spaghetti, Jessy Does Not Forgive…He Kills! (which, mercifully, I have not seen) in 1965. Then he ran a restaurant and wrote books, before filing for bankruptcy. His career in the saddle was less than glittering but he did have something about him, especially as darkish bad guy. In Gunsight Ridge he plays slick but sad gambler Velvet with a past including a failed career as concert pianist.



Cheerful redhead Richard becomes…


…dark bad guy Mark


As was often the case, there are two dames, a ‘good’ one and a racier saloon gal. The good one is named Molly (I am surprised she wasn’t a schoolteacher; she is in fact the sheriff’s daughter) and Joel is attracted to her, naturally, while Rosa is the saucy moll who goes for bad guy Velvet. Joan Weldon takes the part of Molly. You probably remember Joan as Guy Madison’s love interest in The Command or Randolph Scott’s in Riding Shotgun or Fred MacMurray’s in Day of the Badman. Darlene Fields plays Rosa, denizen of the Cobweb Saloon. This and a small part in The Rawhide Years were her only big-screen Westerns.



Joan is Joel’s intended


Good old Addison Richards is the decent though aging Sheriff Tom Jones, Molly’s dad. Solid, dependable character actor in Westerns from the early 1930s on, he never led in one. This was in fact possibly his biggest part in an oater. He was often a respectable townsman in a bit part.



Good old Addison


…is the decent sheriff the townsmen want to depose


Lower down the cast list we have Dan Blocker as the bar tender, Slim Pickens as the stage driver (a drunken yahoo), LQ Jones as one of the reprobate (and equally alcoholic) cowpokes and Joel’s son Jody as Groom.



Joel and Jody
It opens nicely in Arizona scenery (saguaros, etc) with a stage meeting a train. Mike Ryan (McCrea) and Molly disembark from the cars and board the coach. But on the way from the railroad halt to the town of Bancroft, the stage is held up, by a masked man we nevertheless immediately recognize as Mark Stevens, so I don’t know why the driver or passengers couldn’t tell it was Velvet. Ryan is very steady and competent during the robbery. Velvet’s accomplice, a certain Alex (uncredited actor) lets his kerchief slip and is recognized by driver Slim, so Velvet shoots Alex dead, rather callously. He can’t afford to be i/d’d, you see.


Joel has to take over the reins when Slim drinks himself insensible and once in Bancroft he also aids the sheriff disarm and arrest four Lazy Heart cowpokes who are hurrahing the town, showing himself to be handy with a Colt’s, so he’s already proving to be one of those able Westerners who can deal with bad guys. It isn’t long before Sheriff Jones takes him on as a deputy.





Velvet compounds his felony by robbing the bank and planning a train heist, and he has no compunction about gunning down inconvenient interlopers. He’s not a very good chap. But Sheriff Addison and Deputy Joel are on his trail. They have their suspicions, even though Rosa alibis Velvet.


Still, the lawmen can’t pin the criminal down, and the townsmen want to fire the sheriff. Luckily, at this point Ryan reveals himself to be a Wells, Fargo special agent, and he keeps the sheriff in office. They should have known that already. Hadn’t they seen Joel’s 1937 Paramount picture Wells Fargo? He pretty well invented Wells, Fargo. In Westerns Wells, Fargo men seemed as powerful as US marshals, at least judging by Jim Hardie. I suppose Joel could have been a Pinkerton (and in fact he was in The Lone Hand), but sometimes in Westerns the Pinks  were a bit on the baddy side, whereas Wells, Fargo detectives were always goodies.



Ryan suspects Velvet


He hides the loot in a dynamite box. Was that wise?


Well, there’s quite a lot of of action in the last reel, with mucho shootin’ and, of course, rootin’ & tootin’. Velvet has hidden his ill-gotten loot in a dynamite box (he’s a mine owner) strapped to a mule and Sheriff Tom shoots at him, not knowing that, so there’s a big boom, unluckily for the poor beast of burden. There follows a blazing gunfight between mine owner and lawman, and then Deputy/Wells, Fargo man Joel takes up the chase. It’s all go. We finally get to a shoot-out in the rocks, Wichester ’73 style (well, countless Westerns style, really) and you may guess who gets shot and who wins and who gets the girl.


Honestly – and when am I anything less? (hem hem) – Gunsight Ridge is not a top-drawer Western. It’s a bit routine and it doesn’t stand out. Joel was ever so slightly anno domini to be playing an Irish lothario and some of the plot is on the improbable side. The days of the black & white ‘lesser’ Western were numbered, and indeed Joel himself would soon defect to the small screen and do the series Wichita Town. Nevertheless, it’s pretty and there’s plenty of action. Some of the dialogue is entertaining and the picture does stick in the memory a bit more than many minor oaters of the period.




7 Responses

  1. Pretty much agree with your review Jeff and as you state Lyon was certainly not
    much of a director.Nice bit for Carolyn Craig who sadly took her own life.
    Such a shame Joel never continued making films with Jacques Tourneur instead of
    doing two career killers in a row for Lyon and the equally dire Charles Marquis
    Warren. Totally agree regarding Stevens and the splendid JACK SLADE possibly his
    finest hour. Stevens was a fine Noir actor with an impressive list of credits
    including the abrasive CRY VENGEANCE and TIMETABLE both of which he directed.
    No Way was John Payne a poor man's Alan Ladd; Payne,dark and 6'2 and Ladd
    blonde and 5'6.
    Payne was one of the all time great Noir stars and I won't be boring and list
    his great list of credits.Payne made some decent Westerns as well including
    the classic SILVER LODE..if ever a film needed a proper restoration that's it.
    Other good Payne Westerns include ROAD TO DENVER,SANTA FE PASSAGE and the very
    Noirish REBEL IN TOWN. Kino Lorber are soon to release a beauty of a restored
    version of EL PASO one of those splashy Pine Thomas big budget efforts.
    GUNSIGHT RIDGE is NOT a Noir Western I might add,despite Steven's presence.
    If any actor was the "poor man's" Alan Ladd that would be Alan Baxter.

  2. Jeff,before Jerry and Walter get on my case I should add that Warren's real talent
    was as a producer/director of classic TV Western series.
    I always felt that as a director Warren's style,such as it is,was always best
    suited to the small screen…in fact the Warren directed Rawhide episode "Incident
    With An Executioner" with Dan Duryea going full blast was one of that series
    best episodes ever. Oddly enough in the UK GUNSIGHT RIDGE played as the co-feature
    to HIDDEN FEAR the very least of John Payne's Noirs and a well below par effort
    from the normally stellar Andre De Toth.
    TROOPER HOOK was relegated to "floating release" status in the UK (i.e. non major
    circuit) playing bottom half to the B thriller COP HATER. Despite Joel's fallen
    status he did strike back with the excellent FORT MASSACRE and good GUNFIGHT AT
    DODGE CITY the latter,in the UK at least, re-instated Joel as a main feature star.

  3. Good to see John K. roaring 'full blast' and popping at Walter and me. That's more like it!

    I guess we are all in agreement then that this was decidedly lesser McCrea though still pretty enjoyable overall. Lyon was lacking rather as a director of westerns. It certainly wasn't all downhill for Joel though – some weaker films, of which this is one, but the latter 1950s certainly also boasted some that I like a lot (John listed two fine examples) and that includes "CATTLE EMPIRE" for this McCrea fan.

    1. I agree that Joel still had some good Westerns to come.
      Sooner or later I'll get round to a career retrospective of McCrea Westerns, such as I have done for John Wayne, Randolph Scott, et al, but first I want to review all his oaters separately. Next will be The First Texan.
      To go back to John K, I DO think there are noirish elements to Gunsight Ridge, heightened by the crime plot, the black & white and the presence of Mark Stevens. Also the overall quite somber tone.

  4. Ha! Jerry,I thought I was in the dog-house with you regarding my "Old Geezers Brigade"
    comment over at The Hannibal 8. You never came back to me on that one and by the way
    did your Good Lady finally buy you the Boetticher/Scott box set for your recent
    birthday…I hope so!
    Jeff,you will still have to convince me that GUNSIGHT RIDGE is a Noir Western
    I guess we will have to beg to differ on that. I am very interested to hear
    your take on THE FIRST TEXAN and hopefully you will,as always, provide some
    CORRECT historical facts to balance with Dan Ulmann's fiction.
    For me the film is a bit of a snooze fest but rather endearing,all the same.
    If you hang on there is a slam bang (by Allied Artists standards) battle scene
    at the end.I understand box office was nowhere near the rather splendid WICHITA.
    While we're talking later McCrea I am very fond of THE TALL STRANGER fast paced
    and crammed with action,pretty fair cast as well.

  5. It takes more (much more) than being called'an old geezer' to offend me, John. Besides, I am one!

    Glad you mention "THE TALL STRANGER" btw. I saw that in 1957 on the big screen on General Release on the strength of the fact I had already become a fan of Joel McCrea. Loved the film from the off, when he is bushwhacked with that fancy rifle, and I retain a VERY soft spot for it still.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Comments